Case Review
Hamilton Enquiry
Whats New
How to Help

New GuestMap Guest Book.



The Ludlow Family Meet An Taoiseach Bertie Ahern


The British Irish Rights Watch Report - The Hamilton Inquiry - The Barron Inquiry - Terms of Reference - Witness Account - Ludlow Family Account - Sunday World report May 1976 - 25th Anniversary - Profile - Questions -

Meeting the Police Ombudsman  - Ed Moloney Radio Interview - A Fresh Inquest 2005 Inquest Account - Press Release - Letter to  RUCPress Coverage - Barron Report is Published - Download the Barron Report (pdf file) - Statement from Justice for the Forgotten - Joint statement from Justice for the Forgotten, Relatives for Justice and the Pat Finucane Centre - Download Transcript of Ludlow family meeting with the Oireachtas Sub-Committee on Justice on 24-01-06 (Word file) - At the Oireachtas Sub-Committee Hearing: 24 January 2006 - Justice for the Forgotten and British Irish Rights Watch address the Oireachtas Sub-Committee 24 January 2006

The Dundalk Bombing - Dundalk Bombing Report Finds Collusion Download the Barron Report (pdf file) on the Dundalk bombing - Download Oireachtas Report on the Dundalk bombing.

Latest Revised: February 05, 2008.


Seamus Ludlow: murdered 2 May 1976 - The Ludlow family met with Taoiseach Bertie Ahern to discuss proposals for a public inquiry into the cover-up of his death.A group of Ludlow family members were in Dublin on Tuesday 22 January, 2008,  for a meeting at 10.00am with An Taoiseach Bertie Ahern.  

The meeting, at the Department of the Taoiseach, Government Buildings, was also attended by Mr James MacGuill, the Ludlow family solicitor, and by Jane Winter, Director of British Irish Rights Watch (BIRW), London.  Another welcome attendee was Co Louth Fianna Fail TD Seamus Kirk.

Jane Winter has been a valued supporter of the Ludlow family campaign for truth and justice since 1998. She has accompanied the Ludlow family to many such meetings over the years, including meetings with the former minister for justice John O'Donoghue; the former Attorney General Michael McDowell; and the former Northern Ireland Police Ombudsman Nuala O'Loan. She has also compiled an independent Report on the Death Of Seamus Ludlow, which can be found on this site. Just click on the link above.

The Ludlow family appreciates the support of Jane Winter and BIRW and all they have done for the campaign in recent years.

The Ludlow family circle was represented at the meeting with An Taoiseach Bertie Ahern by Seamus' only surviving brother Kevin Ludlow; his sister Mrs Nan Sharkey, and her sons Jimmy and Nicholas Sharkey, and her daughter Mrs Briege Doyle; and nephews Brendan Ludlow and Michael Donegan. Mrs Eileen Fox and Mrs Kathleen Donegan, also sisters of the late Seamus Ludlow, were unable to attend.

An Taoiseach Bertie Ahern finally met with the Ludlow family on 22 January 2008, to discuss their demands for a public inquiry into the murder of Seamus LudlowThe Ludlow family was quite pleased that the meeting went well. The family put its case for a public inquiry into Seamus Ludlow's death, and the Taoiseach listened to it.

As Jimmy Sharkey has been quoted: "It was a very cordial meeting and we are very happy with the outcome."

Though the meeting was indeed cordial throughout, Mr Ahern appeared to show he doesn't favour a public inquiry into the murder of Seamus Ludlow.

He pointed out that an inquiry looking into matters of collusion, the Dublin and Monaghan bombings, Seamus Ludlow and a whole host of other incidents would go on for years and cost millions. There was also the matter of the Six Counties authorities being less than willing to cooperate, as they have been with the previous Barron and Oireachtas inquiries.

Indeed, a number of tribunals of inquiry are already in progress several months, if not years, investigating matters involving, planning, finances and corruption. Some of these inquiries continue with no end in sight, and are costing huge sums of taxpayers' money in terms of legal fees.

The Ludlow family responded that they are not calling for such an expensive or endless inquiry. The Ludlow family can't accept a lengthy inquiry as several members are advanced in years, and they need to see the desired truth and closure as soon as possible. The Ludlow family does not want to waste taxpayer's money unnecessarily, when a more cost-effective and shorter focused inquiry is both possible and desirable..

Kevin Ludlow, only surviving brother of Seamus Ludlow,  spoke on behalf of the Ludlow family at the start of the meeting.And, while British cooperation would be welcome, and indeed helpful, it was the view of the Ludlow family that any British failure to cooperate with a public inquiry into the collusion aspects of Seamus Ludlow's murder in the Iriah State should not be cast as a reason for no inquiry. Such indifference could give rise to inferences that Britain should want to avoid.

As Jimmy Sharkey, again, says: "There was some discussion about collusion but we are more concerned about the cover-up of a murder which took place in this State.

"We feel that a focused independent inquiry to be held over a set period of time would give us some of the answers we've been asking for."

The Ludlow family's demand for a focused independent inquiry was also stated succinctly by Seamus Ludlow's brother Kevin, when he told The Cavan Post, 15 January 2008:

"I stress the word focused as we want the inquiry to look specifically at the findings of the Barron Report (2005) and Jouint Oireachtas Committee Report (2006). We do not want a long drawn out affair that will last for years and cost the taxpayer millions as some of these ongoing tribunals have."

"Our objective is and always has been to find out the truth about our brother's murder. We don't want some kind of financial pay-off, we just want the truth which would enable myself, my three sisters and our extended families to achieve some kind of closure on the case after 32 years and so that Seamus can finally rest in peace."

The family assured Mr Ahern that they don't see any point in re-opening the investigation into Seamus Ludlow's abduction and murder by loyalist paramilitary/UDR personnel as vital files and forensic evidence, including bullets and clothing has been lost. Also, it had long been d4ecided by the Northern Ireland Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) that there would be no prosecutions.

The Ludlow family accepts that it is beyond doubt that the killers are known, even if they can never be brought to justice for their crime! The Ludlow family does not need an inquiry to reveal who drove the car or who fired the shots into Seamus Ludlow's body. The Ludlow family does want an inquiry into who allowed them to escape from justice.

The Ludlow family is only calling for a limited and focused inquiry into the murder of Seamus Ludlow. It would be focused on the questions left by the failure of the Barron and Oireachtas Committee Reports, namely the cover-up, the stalled investigation, the first inquest and other matters in relation to how the Ludlow family was treated after the murder. It would concentrate on the interviewing, under power of subpoena, of witnesses in the Republic of Ireland who would have such information.

It was pointed out that the limited number of witnesses required, mainly gardai and department of justice people, serving or retired,  are in his jurisdiction, along with the files and documentation that are relevant. Such an inquiry should only take a few weeks, months at most. 

It would have the full cooperation of the Ludlow family, as Mr Ahern was assured. The Ludlow family would of course cooperate fully with any focused inquiry as it has likewise cooperated fully with all inquiries to date. 

This process began with an internal Garda inquiry led by Chief Superintendent Ted Murphy (now retired). The family cooperated fully, albeit with certain misgivings as to its failings, with the Hamilton-Barron Inquiry process, which released a report in 2005, and the oral hearings of the Joint Oireachtas Committee which published a report in 2006.

The family, independently, secured the reopening of the inquest by Order of the then Attorney General Michael McDowell, and though the inquest was limited in its scope, the family cooperated and participated as much as it was allowed.

Throughout these processes the Ludlow family has contended that the logical and only satisfactory way of resolving these grave matters once and for all is the holding of a sworn public inquiry. This point was put to Mr Ahern.

It was agreed that Mr James MacGuill, the Ludlow family solicitor would consult with the attorney general (AG) about a list of proposals for a focused inquiry about the family's proposals. It was hoped that the Ludlow family would meet with the AG in the near future. So, we'll see what happens next.

At the closure of the meeting, Seamus Kirk TD, who had been present throughout, kindly remained for a few minutes of discussion, and he was asked to use his influence to have the matter advanced further.

As indicated elsewhere on this Ludlow family website, the Ludlow family had been seeking a meeting with Mr Ahern for the past ten years - but without success. 

It came somewhat as a surprise when Mr Ahern actually told the Ludlow family group that he had in fact met them before a number of times! Not so, Mr Ahern!

He specifically cited one occasion as being the day  back in May 2001 when his cabinet met at the Ballymascanlan Hotel, within 400 metres of the lane where Seamus Ludlow was murdered. The Ludlow family sought a meeting with him that day but he would not meet with them. 

Instead a meeting was held with then Minister for Justice, Mr John O'Donoghue, TD. See The Dundalk Democrat of 19 May 2001 for a report of the Ludlow family's meeting with Mr O'Donoghue at Ballymascanlan.

See also this quote from The Sunday Tribune, 20 May 2001:

The brother and nephew of the 47-year-old forestry worker who was murdered 25 years ago this month attempted to hand a letter to Taoiseach Bertie Ahern at the cabinet meeting at Ballymascanlan Hotel outside Dundalk.

Kevin Ludlow and Jimmy Sharkey presented the letter to Justice Minister John O'Donoghue after they were told the Taoiseach would not be accepting it. . .

The Balymascanlan meeting with Mr O'Donoghue was followed soon after by a disastrous meeting wiith him in Dublin. 

On that occasion the Minister for Justice tried to persuade the Ludlow family to accept the Barron Inquiry. When his bullying tactics failed, the ill-mannered Mr O'Donoghue abruptly left the meeting without saying goodbye. See also The Sunday Business Post, of 17 June 2001, for an article headlined "Murdered man's family says justice minister was 'hostile' ", for a report of this second meeting with the minister for justice.

The Ludlow family soon after  this unfortunate meeting with Mr O'Donoghue joined the Barron Inquiry process on sound legal advice, but not at the persuasion of Mr O'Donoghue.

All of this is to digress from our account of a very favourable meeting with the Taoiseach on 22 January 2008. It serves only to set the record straight.

The Ludlow family appreciate the welcome they received from An Taoiseach Bertie Ahern and his kind staff at the Department of the Taoiseach on 22 January 2008. Mr Ahern was kindly and sympathetic throughout the meeting and he did show a willingnness to listen to the Ludlow family's point of view.

I Top I

See report from The Irish Times newspaper's website ireland.com headlined AG decision on Ludlow inquiry due.

Also: The Argus (Dundalk), 23 January 2008: Family seeking Ludlow inquiry

You will find below links to two brief videos on RTE TV News bulletins from today. They don't say much about the meeting with Mr Ahern, but you may like to view them. Click on the appropriate  video links on the RTE News pages.

RTE 1.pm news, 22 January 2008:

I Top I

Remember: You can download to your computer a complete copy of the Barron Report on the murder of Seamus Ludlow  from the Oireachtas website (pdf file)

You can also download the Final Oireachtas Sub-Committee Report on the murder of Seamus Ludlow from the Oireachtas website (pdf file)

Visitors are welcome to leave messages on our new Bravenet guestmap Guest Book. You can indicate your country or state of origin by using the map supplied.

The Ludlow family supports the campaign by the Rooney and Watters families of Dundalk for an inquiry into the murderous Dundalk Bombing of 19 December 1975 which resulted in the sectarian murder of Jack Rooney and Hugh Watters. 

A  Barron Report on this other sectarian attack in Dundalk, and other attacks along the border, was published 5 July 2006. 

An Oireachtas sub-committee also held public hearings on the Dundalk bombing and issued a further report on 29 November 2006.

The Oireachtas report found damning evidence of British state collusion between UK army and intelligence agencies and loyalist terrorists in this and other atrocities along the border.

It is hardly surprising that to this date the British government has made no comment whatsoever about these serioius charges!


Download the Barron Report (pdf file) on the Dundalk bombing.

Download the International Report on Collusion from the Pat Finucane Centre website

Download the Oireachtas Report on the Dundalk bombing and other collusion attacks

Further information can be accessed at their Dundalk bombing campaign website.

Also visit:
Relatives for Justice:  http://www.relativesforjustice.com/
Pat Finucane Centre: http://www.patfinucanecentre.org
British Irish Rights Watch: http://www.birw.org/
Irish Council for Civil Liberties:  http://www.iccl.ie/
Celtic League:  http://www.manxman.co.im/cleague/index.html
Justice for the Forgotten: http://www.dublinmonaghanbombings.org/


The 1st. Barron Report on the May 1974 Dublin and Monaghan bombings can be downloaded in pdf format from: http://www.irlgov.ie/oireachtas/Committees-29th-D%E1il/jcjedwr-debates/InterimDubMon.pdf

Download the MacEntee Commission of Investigation's Final Report on the Dublin and Monaghan bombings of 17 May 1974 from the Justice for the Forgotten group's campaign website.

The 2nd.Barron Report on the Dublin Bombings of 1972 and 1973, and other incidents along the Irish border, can be downloaded in pdf form from: http://www.oireachtas.ie/documents/committees29thdail/jcjedwr/Dublin_Barron_Rep031204.pdf


Back to Top.I View our  Original Guestbook


Webspace donated and hosted by Thirtytwo.Net
 Page last updated on 05 February 2008

Copyright © 2008 the Ludlow family. All rights reserved.